JOIN
Get Time
forums   
Search | Watch Thread  |  My Post History  |  My Watches  |  User Settings
View: Flat (newest first)  | Threaded  | Tree
Previous Thread  |  Next Thread
Checkpoint Feedback Posted! | Reply
Hi Everyone,

In case you didn't notice, we already post checkpoint feedback for this challenge and it can be found at this link:

https://www.topcoder.com/challenges/30061196/?type=design&noncache=true&tab=checkpoints

I will post all checkpoint feedback in this thread shortly, stay tuned guys!

Best Regards,

fajar.mln
Re: Checkpoint Feedback Posted! (response to post by fajar.mln) | Reply
Checkpoint Placements:
- 247557
- 247558
- 247559
- 247560
- 247593
Re: Checkpoint Feedback Posted! (response to post by fajar.mln) | Reply
General Feedback
- Great Start Everyone!
- In dashboard, need to see various ways to see the API, gallery/list view.
- Make sure to provide clear UX for the User and Administrator for all features asked in the challenge.
- Would like to see more "action" shots depicting how tiles are engaged. Slide, shadow effects or highlight actioning.
- Would like to see the preview on the admin pages and need to see ability to adding a new API, also we would like to see more edit API options.
- Originally, we wanted to see screen captures for icon's of the APIs, but you also can use brand type icons for this. We think using brand icon's catches the eye better and overall is a better feel.
- Search function, need to split the search results into two groups, one showing what APIs the user has already requested, and the other showing what is also available. This is something that really caught the eye to a few of our employees.
- Looking forward to seeing your final design
- Thank you.
Re: Checkpoint Feedback Posted! (response to post by fajar.mln) | Reply
247557
- Like the logo creation
- Would like to see an option to switch to list view on page 3 (Dashboard).
- Would like to see the "ICON" text changed using some real icons so we know how it looks like in the real app.
- Search API in screen 2_2_1, it feels too empty, can add some suggestion, recent search, etc?
- What will admin see after they login to the app? How do they open screen 3_1? also, would like to see the gallery version for this screen
- screen 3_1, did the "add new" and "delete" button disable here? what happens when the user clicks the edit button on the list?
- In add new API, add link area to connect to API server. There should be a 'sync' features to import API codes
- Everything else looks clean and easy to use.
- Like the color scheme and use of white space.
- Looking forward to seeing your final design
- Thank you.

247558
- Not sure about the logo
- Like the slide for getting started instruction
- Pay attention to details, the ratio between each design element needs to be the same, for ex. the "Dashboard" text in screen 2-1 feels too small, the same thing with the hamburger menu
- Screen 2-1, the good/issues/error just need to be an indicator light, no need for text.
- How do administrators add new API? there is no button on the dashboard to create it?
- how does user do a transition from 4-1 to 4-2 screens? how does user do the preview on screen 4-3-2?
- Lots of details on the Administration portion, but no screen for an ordinary user?
- Want to see more on how someone requests an API or even what the full view of the API looks like when selected.
- Overall though, like the design and feel.
- Looking forward to seeing your final design
- Thank you.

247559
- Need to see the Android version too in final round
- Dashboard, need to see the API as a list view too (for user)
- like the filter area
- Good to see some additional features added here, like the rating, etc
- For API Status, it cannot use up/down arrow, it needs to be a light indicator (green, yellow, red)
- How can user request new API?
- Like the design, wish there was more content showing the admin portal
- Looking forward to seeing your final design
- Thank you.
Re: Checkpoint Feedback Posted! (response to post by fajar.mln) | Reply
247560
- Really like look and feel of the demo.
- Looks very promising.
- How do we trigger the carousel option on screen 02_2?
- 02_10, on request, should have different colors, not grey
- 02_2 would like to see API options and preview first before do "RUN API"
- If user not an administrator, what will be shown on 03_1 screen?
- Want more details on the experience of adding an API.
- Looking forward to seeing your final design
- Thank you.

247561
- Looks promising, but only 2 screens? Need to see more.
- some design elements feel too small, need to pay attention to design ratio
- dashboard, need to see the list view too
- would like to see the API server status on the dashboard
- Looking forward to seeing your final design
- Thank you.

247580
- Not a fan of the layout. Feels too cookie-cutter.
- Dashboard, For API list, avoid using stock photo, user icons to presented the API
- Dashboard, the "+" button not indicate view or run API, but more like add new API, so it does not bring good UX
- Like to see the dashboard summary, love the API chart, need to see more of this.
- Not sure about the API interaction, the UX need to improve.
- Looking forward to seeing your final design
- Thank you.
Re: Checkpoint Feedback Posted! (response to post by fajar.mln) | Reply
247584
- Too busy, so much going on it seems easy to get lost in the details.
- did not like the artwork here
- Dashboard screen 2, why it goes directly to API details?
- how do I go from API details to Explore API>
- How to request new API?
- Clean up the UX, it's messed up right now.
- Looking forward to seeing your final design
- Thank you.

247585
- The login animation is fun to look at, but the rest of the demo is lacking.
- Dashboard needs to be improved, we can't see only the icon, need to see summary of the API too
- The design too premature, need to see more.
- Looking forward to seeing your final design
- Thank you.

247593
- The design concept is fantastic, but we need to see more (requesting API, preview API, RUN API, etc)
- Dashboard will be great to be able to see the list as gallery view too
- Admin, Add, Edit...Would like to see more on the filter button action as well.
- Looking forward to seeing your final design
- Thank you.
Re: Checkpoint Feedback Posted! (response to post by fajar.mln) | Reply
Okay, all checkpoint feedback has been posted, let's continue to 2nd round now. We are very excited to see your final design. Please don't hesitate to ask anything related to the challenge requirements or checkpoint feedback in this forum. For an information, the 2nd round deadline will come on "Jan 05, 2018 at 10:02 EST" or about 6 days from now. Thank you and good luck everyone!
Re: Checkpoint Feedback Posted! (response to post by fajar.mln) | Reply
Thank you for the feedback.

Regarding this line:
- Originally, we wanted to see screen captures for icon's of the APIs, but you also can use brand type icons for this. We think using brand icon's catches the eye better and overall is a better feel.

Q: any helps or references for brand icon?
Re: Checkpoint Feedback Posted! (response to post by basuki) | Reply
Hi basuki,

I'm checking with the client about your question and will get back to you asap, please wait for a moment, thank you.

Best Regards,

fajar.mln
Re: Checkpoint Feedback Posted! (response to post by basuki) | Reply
basuki,

Regarding your question earlier, here is client clarification:

We don't have any references, so, any icon that show the thumbnail icon as the branded example will be fine for this.
RSS