JOIN
Get Time
forums   
Search | Watch Thread  |  My Post History  |  My Watches  |  User Settings
View: Flat (newest first)  | Threaded  | Tree
Previous Thread  |  Next Thread
[ 1 2 ]    NEXT >
Rolling Checkpoint Feedback | Reply
Here is the initial rolling checkpoint feedback. The client is still reviewing and may have additional comments later. We will post any updates. Great job so far!

247129
- Great start
- Like the color usage and general layouts here
- Have a "quick list" of popular APIs on the homepage is a nice idea. Allows the user to quickly jump in
- API list is good. Like the filtering and sorting functionality
- I know you have a global search, but might be nice to have search just for APIs to help refine/ find exactly what you are looking for. Maybe the ability to stack or combine search terms?
- Knowledge center page content needs to be updated
- Like the whitepaper layout. Visually interesting. How would this work if there are numerous papers though. Any additional functionality we can add here to make larger amounts of content easier to find/ sort through?
- Really great start overall

247165
- This is an interesting idea for the layout, but I would want to see what the interior pages to better understand the user flows. Right now it's a little confusing
- Not sure why there is a sound setting?
- The hamburger nav and bottom nav seem redundant. Again would want to see the interior pages, maybe the hamburger nav will make more sense there.
- The opened hamburger nav is a little overwhelming though. Not sure it needs to be an entire screen take over. Maybe look at refining this experience a bit more.

247185
- Good start
- Be mindful of legibility and accessibility of users. The white and light gray color scheme doesn't have enough contrast in areas. The separation of content is hard to see
- Like the idea of showing APIs on the homepage, but how can you drive people to the full API list easier/ faster
- The API list page has some legibility issues with the light gray and white again. Hard to see what is a button, tab, dropdown, etc. Need more contrast to make this more user friendly.
- Interesting layouts throughout. Just hard to use in areas. Work on refining the experience from a color scheme and overall experience perspective

247186
- The large homepage icons are ok, but they dont really tell me anything. Maybe this could be treated more as a background pattern or texture?
- Like the API list page. Make sure the contrast of elements is high enough to be usable and legible. The light gray drop shadows are causing some issues.
- Make sure the red doesn't become too overpowering. Maybe try mixing in some other subtle colors to help balance it out?
- Love the icon use throughout

247158
- Interesting layout
- There are some legibility issues with the light colored background and the light gray/ white UI elements
- The API list is somewhat confusing with the various categories being shown in the list "Top ranking", "all", etc. Try to make this more clear somehow
- Nice job overall. Keep pushing and refining this.

247201
- Clean and well organized layouts. Nice job
- The subtle design elements and great typography add visual interest without being overpowering or " in your face". I like this
- Looking forward to seeing what the rest of the pages look like

247167
- Like the hero image, but the rest of the page seems a little less refined
- Not a lot to really review though. Would want to see more to get a sense of the UI and overall user experience

247159
- Nice start
- Like the variety of content and interactions
- The different layouts functionality adds nice visually interest
- Keep pushing this forward
Re: Rolling Checkpoint Feedback (response to post by tgerring) | Reply
For the other submissions, will they get some feedback?
Thanks
Re: Rolling Checkpoint Feedback (response to post by tgerring) | Reply
2417168
- This is a good start.
- Good work with colors and Typography.
- Your bottom section is great
- General layout is good but is on a safe area right now
- Would be great to see some new concepts, especially on the landing page.
- APIs page is good. Wondering how the list view would look?
- You are on the right path
- Keep pushing for final submission

2417169
- This is an interesting layout and concepts overall
- However, it seems that you have different styles, like cartoony on landing, then flat on insights, and finally clean and minimalist on about us.
- Looks like different websites merged into one
- The style applied to "About us" section is the best match for this challenge.
- Try to bring that style to other pages and you will be on the right way
- Keep pushing and refining this

2417300
- Really great star. So clean and elegant
- The landing page is great, however, what is more important for user that enter into this site? About us or APIs?
- APIs section is great! Really well organized.
- Overall color and layout are well done. Feels clean, minimalist and elegant
- You are on the right path
- Keep pushing for final submission
Re: Rolling Checkpoint Feedback (response to post by riopurba) | Reply
Hi Rio,

I think all feedback have been shared. Let me know if still missing yours.
Re: Rolling Checkpoint Feedback (response to post by chekspir) | Reply
Thanks for the feedback. Now I'm preparing my final submission.
Re: Rolling Checkpoint Feedback (response to post by chekspir) | Reply
Alex, except for the home screen, the other links are not working.

It says:
TelkomAPISummary Portlet is temporarily unavailable.

Can you check please
Re: Rolling Checkpoint Feedback (response to post by riopurba) | Reply
Looking forward to your final submission Rio Purba
Re: Rolling Checkpoint Feedback (response to post by Ravijune) | Reply
Hi Ravi,

Which link is not working exactly? I just checked them all and are working on my end.
Re: Rolling Checkpoint Feedback (response to post by chekspir) | Reply
This link (API list) http://uat.telkomxsight.com/en/web/telkom/product-summary is also taking down.
Re: Rolling Checkpoint Feedback (response to post by riopurba) | Reply
I already forwarded this to PM and admins. Lets see what they can do.

Sorry for this issue
Re: Rolling Checkpoint Feedback (response to post by chekspir) | Reply
Great!

Also, Alex what things that client expects for this challenge after rolling checkpoint review?

Thanks in advance.
Re: Rolling Checkpoint Feedback (response to post by riopurba) | Reply
I've been having the exact same problem on & off since yesterday I think we're hitting their server more than they accounted for.

I took screen dumps that I've been using myself if anyone wants them

https://drive.google.com/drive/folders/1QjLZnkyYZcWGtODYTAeWE08LZcSf7Rui?usp=sharing
Re: Rolling Checkpoint Feedback (response to post by 0rpheus) | Reply
Awesome. Thanks man! :D
Re: Rolling Checkpoint Feedback (response to post by 0rpheus) | Reply
Thanks Orpheus!

Alex, the links are still not working! Working on this challenge would be faster if we have them work. (Copy+paste text etc.)

Do you think it's fair to extend the challenge for few hours because of this issue?

Thank you
Re: Rolling Checkpoint Feedback (response to post by chekspir) | Reply
I would like to know what categories are available from API page. The drop down.

Seems like this is quite not fair for someone joining the challenge on the last day :|
The links are still broken and I am half way through!
[ 1 2 ]    NEXT >

RSS