JOIN
Get Time
forums   
Search | Watch Thread  |  My Post History  |  My Watches  |  User Settings
View: Flat (newest first)  | Threaded  | Tree
Previous Thread  |  Next Thread
<< PREV    [ 1 2 ]
Re: Writing name /handle like "Submission-JamesBond" & in Readme file. (response to post by hi4sandy) | Reply
What section in the UI prototype scorecard is responsible for that?
How much deduction should he get?
Re: Writing name /handle like "Submission-JamesBond" & in Readme file. (response to post by Sky_) | Reply
reviewer-1 imp. Issues missed/ignored:
- "1_22.png , 1_23.png & 1_24.png" storyboard pages both layout & functional for the other submission (sections 2.1.1 & 2.1.2 having score weight 40 , 40 respectively)
- submission name issue (section 2.1.4) (score weight: 20)

reviewer-2 Issues missed/ignored: 1 section for 2nd reviewer
- "1_22.png , 1_23.png & 1_24.png" storyboard pages both layout & functional for the other submission (sections 2.1.1 & 2.1.2 having score weight 40 , 40 respectively)
- submission name issue (section 2.1.4)

* Their are other missed things those don't have big impact.
Re: Writing name /handle like "Submission-JamesBond" & in Readme file. (response to post by hi4sandy) | Reply
https://software.topcoder.com/review/actions/ViewScorecard?scid=30001450

Question 2.1.4 Is the prototype designed to support maintainability (easy to support and modify)? A maintainable application is defined as one that uses technology in a way that other developers will be able to understand and support / update if needed. If non-standard coding techniques are used, they should include easy following comments or documentation. This full definition of "maintainability" is covered in detail on the UI Prototype Overview page.
3 - Strongly Agree - Yes, the design supports maintainability.
2 - Agree - There are several issues that may affect maintainability. (please specify)
1 - Disagree - The design contains significant issues that will make it difficult to maintain, such as many hard-coded elements. (please specify)
0 - Strongly Disagree - The design contains serious maintainability issues and cannot properly be supported or maintained. (please specify)


I don't see anything about including submitter handle.
Re: Writing name /handle like "Submission-JamesBond" & in Readme file. (response to post by Sky_) | Reply
Many things are not listed in scorecard. Even you cant find anything about cheating & new technologies. But they are scored-down in some related sections.
Few years ago the ppl. removed the handles from submissions in OR & other pages to improve transparency in review. If you can search through older forum pages, you'll find.

Don't we write TCASSEMBLER in author section of DG?

I may not be able to answer further que. because concerned ppl. aren't listening.

Thanks
<< PREV    [ 1 2 ]

RSS