Member Search
|
|
Search
|
Watch Thread | My Post History | My Watches | User Settings View: Flat (newest first) | Threaded | Tree Previous Thread | Next Thread |
||
Forums
Design Forums
IBM Email Client Mobile Design Challenge
Non Checkpoint Winner Feedback
|
||
| Non Checkpoint Winner Feedback | Reply | |
| 222233 - Overall it would be useful if you label your images - Indox: You start off showing a swipe action - what does this screen look like before any action is taken? - Inbox: Swipe action colors do not seem consistent in hue (green is very bright compared to everything else) - Inbox: Top area - you have a lot of different actions going on. The mobile view will need to be simple - complexity of the sliders? Will this work on all mobile - New message could stand out even more. - probably do not need advanced text editing on mobile. - looks good. 222238 - small click targets. - Has the filtering / people at top! - Busy/Complex. - Seems like a smaller version of the desktop - not solving for the mobile space - See overall feedback. 222239 - Too complicated - Important features are not called out well. - feels incomplete. - Applies color (check on if this usage makes sense) - Sizing is small - focus on mobile appropriate sizes 222301 - Refine your design further. - See overall feedback. 222302 - something different. Like the color options. - Nav bar is very cluttered. So many options. - Need quick links. - Appears to be using the IBM Design Language (great use of grid) - Looks simple to use but 508 issues with just "icons" - we would need the labels - Just showing bars of icons is confusing (I would need to know what they all mean) ---- Group refine links and attachments icons. Group refresh and thread together. Move search somewhere that it can stand out better. ---- Search feels misplaced. Needs to be separated from the filters. ---- All the actions have the same weight/size - so fix the hierarchy (how things are grouped) - Looks good. Like the effort to change color schemes. 222303 - Like how search functions. - Well thought through. - 508 issues where we need labels (see what our approach/clear answer on this) - Compose (do we need the drop down items on mobile?) This does a good job of calling attention to the key actions. - See overall feedback. 222312 - Incomplete. Need the required screens. - Like the huge compose button but it is a bit overkill. - See overall feedback. 222316 - Have the proper checklist items too large. - Layout needs work. Placing of icons / items. - Color usage isn't consistent - Visualizing how messages are grouped (looks good) - See overall feedback. 222317 - Good. - Threading looks worked out. - Sliders? Not sure we can do it. - Filters seems awkward/a lot of steps (missing refinements) - Quick access links. - Compose is nice. - See overall feedback. 222318 - Has the necessary things. Size is an issue. - Remove "Castle" -Press and hold for compose options is not going to work. Dropdown list could work. - Cc / Bcc lists are weird; two lines. - Folders list is interesting. Might not work if a user has a ton of folders. Can this go in sidebar menu? Or dropdown below? (two columns might not work) (need a way to add a new folder). - Seem to be missing search. - Icons / options on message threads are overwhelming. Where to simplify? - Compose: Timing bottom left work/nice approach - Sent email - colors? Take over of the screen seems awkward not in line with the design 222321 - Visually, colors are too far from verse app. -Missing many key elements. -Too much like a iphone app. 222322 - Too much space for filtering features / important people. Pull those in. - Need icons on your menu. It all blends together. Pull from Existing app. - Threading looks ok. - See overall feedback. 222324 - Too incomplete. - Good start though. - Like the quick access links. - See overall feedback. 222326 - Like the search dropdown. - recent people are too hidden. - Compose is too hidden. - See overall feedback. 222350 - Good start. - Good layout. Needs some refinements. - Top of layout is too cluttered. Simplify. Find a better spot for user quick links. - See overall feedback. 222351 - Good start. - Needs further refinements. - Color scheme is hard to follow. Too white and blue. Introduce more greys and other colors to offer simple divisions of space. - See overall feedback. 222352 - Like the labels on the main screen. Inbox / needs action / waiting for. Simplifies things quick filtering. - The tabbed approach works well. - Cant have fullscreen takeovers for the filters EG: refine list. Need to stay on same screen. - Too many icons and functions in one spot. I dont know where to click or look. - See overall feedback. 222313 - Hiding lots of functions behind the stacked dots - Difficult to understand the flow. - Too reliant upon unlabled icons. - See overall feedback. 222888 - Too many functions hidden behind the ... Need to be able to delete a message more easily. - Need easier way to switch between inbox and other filtered message lists. Not a fan of the dropdown. - Too many things happening on top nav bar. |
|
| Re: Non Checkpoint Winner Feedback (response to post by lunarkid) | Reply | |
| Hi lunarkid, Can you provide more details for my submission (ID : 222326) Can I still improve current branding for final round or need to change all? Thank you! |
|
| Re: Non Checkpoint Winner Feedback (response to post by khanhlinh) | Reply | |
| Hi, Some of the submissions has a comment about not sure about slider. Should we remove it or try to enhance it? Thank you! | |
| Re: Non Checkpoint Winner Feedback (response to post by khanhlinh) | Reply | |
| khanhlinh, For this moment, please address General Feedback requirements. |
|
| Re: Thread "Non Checkpoint Winner Feedback" in category "Design Forums" has been updated by johan_92 (response to post by johan_92) | Reply | |
| johan_92, Think about better/simple solution as slider replacement |
|
| Re: Thread (response to post by lunarkid) | Reply | |
| Hi, What slider? did you mean date navigator? Thanks |
|
| Re: Thread (response to post by ioyik) | Reply | |
| It's specific slider function from other submitter | |
|
Forums
Design Forums
IBM Email Client Mobile Design Challenge
Non Checkpoint Winner Feedback
Previous Thread | Next Thread |
 |